Contextualized self: When the self runs into social dilemmas
International Journal of Psychology, Vol. 44, No. 6, pg. 451-458, 2009.
Chang-Jiang Liu,
Shu Li
Research on the construction of self and of others has indicated that
the way that individuals construe themselves and others exerts an
important influence on their cognition, emotion, and even behavior. The
present study extends this line of research to mixed-motive situations
in which short-term individual and long-term collective interests are
at odds. In addition, this study associates the importance of context
interdependence, and specifically its interaction with independent
self-construal, with an individual's cooperative behavior. We used a
priming task to manipulate the level of self-construal and also
manipulated the degree of interdependent context by giving participants
a chance to assign rewards either to their group members or to
themselves alone. The results showed that when participants received
interdependent (as opposed to independent) self-construal priming, they
consistently contributed highly, regardless of context manipulation. In
contrast, those primed with an independent self-construal contributed
less in the investment game, but only when placed in a context where
group members were encouraged to think about their individual (versus
mutual) fate. In this situation they contributed the least to the group
in the game. These findings indicate that independent self-construal in
a low interdependence context produces the most competitive behavior.
The results also showed that how participants felt about their
interaction with other group members mediated the effect of context
interdependence on cooperative behavior, and possibly that was
especially the case for independent self-construal. The results
demonstrate that the self can be contextualized and embedded in the
social contexts and symbolic systems within which people live.
Read the article.